[vsnet-alert 10386] Re: YSOs from a Symbiotic Star catalogue

[Martin Nicholson]

--- bydra at Safe-mail.net wrote:

<lengthy cut> 

I am not convinced that detailed analysis of this type should appear in vsnet-alert. There are
more suitable venues - both formal and informal - for critiques of this type which in any event I
would much prefered to have seen interspersed with explanations or justifications from the
authors of the article in question. 

Arne Henden argues this exact point most persuasively in AAVSO-DIS and I have nothing to add to
the points he made.
(http://mira.aavso.org/pipermail/aavso-discussion/2008-February/014023.html)

Martin Nicholson
Daventry, UK