[vsnet-alert 14924] Re: Possible bright CV in Peg? - PNVJ23272715+0855391
varsao at hotmail.com
Fri Sep 14 08:51:35 JST 2012
> An object with such a large outburst amplitude should most likely be a
> WZ Sge-type DN, this is why it is really surprising that it had an
> outburst just 12.5 years ago. I made a simple virtual experiment with
> NSVS data checking the light curve of a nearby star 2MASS
> 23272242+0855291 (J-K=0.74) 1.2' away, and it also has an outburst in
> ROTSE-I data: http://skydot.lanl.gov/nsvs/star.php?num=11851348&mask=32004
> (though on the different date). Not that I don't trust NSVS - after
> all, I have found there a real outburst of RX J2319.6+3647 blended
> with a 14.2m star 18" away. What I want to say is: perhaps two
> outlying points on a single night are not an "ironclad" evidence of
> the outburst.
I think you're right. I had not noticed such large amplitude outliers
before. Since they come in pairs, wrong observations usually have a large
difference between each other (in the pair). But here it doesn't seem to be
the case. Even the error figures are small in your example.
Furthermore, there is a confirmation of the outburst not being real in the
case of your star:
Almost simultaneous observations in this synonym showing no outburst.
I notice that the data after 2451532 is brighter here too. No observations
here at the date of the outburst (1565) in the NSVS data for the CV position
though so a comparison is not possible.
This brighter star is 71" away from the dwarf nova so contamination is still
possible although unlikely.
In any case, the blended NSVS light curve of the two stars in the area of
the CV shows a brightening of two magnitudes. It might be a coincidence or
not. Your finding in the other star has proved that it can't be confirmed,
but can't be ruled out either.
American Association of Variable Star Observers
More information about the vsnet-alert