TITLE: GCN CIRCULAR
NUMBER: 36286
SUBJECT: LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA S240422ed: No significant counterpart candidates in HAWC observations
DATE: 24/04/24 16:02:42 GMT
FROM: Hugo Ayala at Pennsylvania State University <hgayala(a)psu.edu>
The HAWC Collaboration (https://www.hawc-observatory.org) reports:
The HAWC Collaboration performed a follow-up of the gravitational wave
trigger S240422ed (GCN 36236). At the time of the trigger the HAWC
local zenith was oriented towards (RA, Dec) = (77.6 deg, 19.0 deg).
36% of the GW candidate sky location probability fell within our
observable field of view (0-45 deg zenith angle).
We performed a search for a short timescale emission using 6 sliding
time windows (dt = 0.3s, 1s, 3s, 10s, 30s and 100s), shifted forward
in time by 20% of their width. We searched the 95% probability
containment area in a timescale-dependent time period, from t0-5dt to
t0+10dt, where t0 is the time of the GW trigger.
No significant gamma-ray detection above the background was observed.
The sensitivity of this analysis is greatly dependent on zenith angle,
ranging from 49.8deg to 60deg for the area searched in this
analysis. The 5sigma detection sensitivity to a 1s (100s) burst in the
80-800GeV energy range goes from 9.9e-5 erg/cm^2 to 4.4e-4 erg/cm^2
(5.6e-4 erg/cm^2 to 2.5e-03 erg/cm^2), depending on the zenith
angle.
A list of some of the hotspots found in the search is shown below. We found
that one of the galaxies that are mentioned in GCN 36235 is close
to one of the observed hotspots.
No hotspot was close to the updated list in GCN 36243.
We mark with a “>” the hotspots that still show up in the updated localization
of the GW (GCN 36240).
Timescale 3 seconds
RA Dec Unc. TS Galaxy
126.21 -8.61 0.83 10.97
> 126.91 -16.10 0.85 11.47
Timescale 10 seconds
RA Dec Unc. TS Galaxy
124.80 -9.97 0.49 12.31
> 126.65 -16.49 0.71 9.27
Timescale 30 seconds
RA Dec Unc. TS Galaxy
124.80 -9.97 0.49 9.01
> 127.53 -15.71 0.64 9.15
Timescale 100 seconds
RA Dec Unc. TS Galaxy
110.65 -27.95 0.50 9.23
113.99 -20.42 0.37 10.23
114.08 -19.87 0.50 9.29
114.26 -21.94 0.52 11.29
120.94 -13.32 0.59 13.33 WISEA J080028.14-134847.4 (0.95deg)
128.23 -10.20 0.39 12.79
> 129.46 -16.49 0.55 12.06
HAWC is a TeV gamma ray water Cherenkov array located in the state of
Puebla, Mexico. It is sensitive to the energy range ~0.1-100TeV, and
monitors 2/3 of the sky every day with an instantaneous field-of-view
of ~2 sr.
View this GCN Circular online at https://gcn.nasa.gov/circulars/36286.
---
To unsubscribe, open this link in a web browser:
https://gcn.nasa.gov/unsubscribe/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJlbWFpbCI6InZzbmV0L…
TITLE: GCN CIRCULAR
NUMBER: 36285
SUBJECT: LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA S240422ed: Vetting of DECam Candidates Using Real-Time Resources and SAGUARO Infrastructure
DATE: 24/04/24 16:01:50 GMT
FROM: Jillian Rastinejad at Northwestern Univ. <jillianrastinejad2024(a)u.northwestern.edu>
Jillian C. Rastinejad (NU), David J. Sand (UA), Griffin Hosseinzadeh (UA), Charles D. Kilpatrick (NU), Wen-fai Fong (NU), Manisha Shrestha (UA), Jennifer E. Andrews (Gemini), K. Azalee Bostroem (UA), Philip N. Daly (UA), Michael J. Lundquist (Keck), Kerry Paterson (MPIA), Jeniveve Pearson (UA), Samuel D. Wyatt (GSFC) report:
We performed a vetting analysis of the candidates reported from the DECam GW-MMADS follow-up (Hu et al. 2024, GCN 36273). Following the methods outlined in Rastinejad et al. (2022) and Hosseinzadeh et al. (2024), we crossmatch each candidate with the TNS (Gal-Yam 2021) and point source catalogs (Tachibana and Miller 2018; Jayasinghe et al. 2019; Flesch et al. 2021; Gaia Collaboration 2023), search public ZTF photometry (Bellm et al. 2019), and run ATLAS forced photometry (Shingles et al. 2021) at the position of the candidate to rule out transients unrelated to the GW event. We determine a most likely host galaxy using the probability of chance coincidence method (Pcc; Bloom et al. 2002) and search for an associated spectroscopic or photometric redshift in public galaxy catalogs (White et al. 2011; Alam et al. 2015; Beck et al. 2016, 2021; Dalya et al. 2021; DESI Collaboration et al. 2023).
Candidate | Vetting result
——————————————————————————————————
AT2024hdk | Three marginal (~3-sigma) ATLAS forced photometry
| detections ~3-5 days prior to GW event.
AT2024hdl | Marginal (~4-sigma) ATLAS forced photometry detection ~4
| days prior to GW event.
AT2024hdm | Marginal (<5-sigma) ATLAS forced photometry detections ~2
| months to 4 days prior to GW event.
AT2024hdn | Five ATLAS forced photometry detections ~4-24 days prior to
| GW event.
AT2024hdo | Associated (Pcc = 0.002) with host galaxy
| WISEJ080327.75-260039.2 from GLADE at z = 0.09 +/- 0.02
| (photometric redshift; D = 404 Mpc).
AT2024hdp | Associated (Pcc < 0.001) with host galaxy
| WISEJ080210.31-271529.7 from GLADE at z = 0.09 +/- 0.02
| (photometric redshift; D = 411 Mpc). ATLAS forced
| photometry detections ~3-18 days prior to GW event.
AT2024hdq | ZTF detections indicate periodic behavior since 2022.
AT2024hdr | ZTF detections in 2021-2022. ATLAS forced photometry
| detections extending >200 days prior to GW event.
Overall, we determine that AT2024hdq and AT2024hdr are unrelated to S240422ed. We find candidates AT2024hdn, AT2024hdm, AT2024hdk, AT2024hdl and AT2024hdp to be likely unrelated to the GW event based on detections prior to the GW event, though we note the significance of the detections varies. In particular, combined with previously reported color and spectroscopic information, we strongly disfavor AT2024hdn and AT2024hdm as the counterparts of S240422ed (Tinyanont et al. 2024, GCN 36281; Karambelkar et al. 2024, GCN 36279). Finally, for AT2024hdo, while the most probable host galaxy photometric redshift is inconsistent with the GW-inferred distance, we cannot rule it out as a possible counterpart given large uncertainties in photometric redshift estimates in the Local Universe.
SAGUARO stands for Searches After Gravitational-waves Using ARizona's Observatories (Hosseinzadeh et al. 2024). It is a partnership between the University of Arizona and Northwestern University.
View this GCN Circular online at https://gcn.nasa.gov/circulars/36285.
---
To unsubscribe, open this link in a web browser:
https://gcn.nasa.gov/unsubscribe/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJlbWFpbCI6InZzbmV0L…
TITLE: GCN CIRCULAR
NUMBER: 36283
SUBJECT: IceCube-240424A - IceCube observation of a high-energy neutrino candidate track-like event
DATE: 24/04/24 14:00:19 GMT
FROM: A. Zegarelli at Ruhr University Bochum <azegarelli(a)icecube.wisc.edu>
The IceCube Collaboration (http://icecube.wisc.edu/) reports:
On 2024-04-24 at 01:49:26.0 UT IceCube detected a track-like event with a high probability of being of astrophysical origin. The event was selected by the ICECUBE_Astrotrack_GOLD alert stream. The average astrophysical neutrino purity for Gold alerts is 50%. This alert has an estimated false alarm rate of 1.225 events per year due to atmospheric backgrounds. The IceCube detector was in a normal operating state at the time of detection.
After the initial automated alert (https://gcn.gsfc.nasa.gov/notices_amon_g_b/139315_50057906.amon), more sophisticated reconstruction algorithms have been applied offline, with the direction refined to:
Date: 2024-04-24
Time: 01:49:26.0 UT
RA: 327.08 (+2.06, -1.70 deg 90% PSF containment) J2000
Dec: 3.06 (+1.37, -1.33 deg 90% PSF containment) J2000
We encourage follow-up by ground and space-based instruments to help identify a possible astrophysical source for the candidate neutrino.
Two Fermi-LAT sources (listed in the 4FGL-DR4 or 3FHL catalogs) are located in the 90% uncertainty region. The nearest gamma-ray source in either catalog is 4FGL J2149.6+0323 (J2149.8+0322 in the 3FHL catalog) at RA: 327.42 deg and DEC: 3.40 deg (0.5 deg away from the best-fit position). The second one is 4FGL J2146.8+0425 at RA: 326.71 deg and DEC: 4.43 deg, 1.4 deg away from the best-fit position. The former source is associated with a BL Lac object, while the latter is a blazar candidate of uncertain type.
Additionally, we note that a recent GRB triggered by the Swift Burst Alert Catalog (BAT) on April 19, 2024 (GRB 240419B, detection time 2024-04-19 12:22:52 UT, GCN Circular #36180), is contained within the 90% uncertainty region of the neutrino candidate event, ~1.7 deg from its best-fit position.
The IceCube Neutrino Observatory is a cubic-kilometer neutrino detector operating at the geographic South Pole, Antarctica. The IceCube realtime alert point of contact can be reached at roc(a)icecube.wisc.edu
View this GCN Circular online at https://gcn.nasa.gov/circulars/36283.
---
To unsubscribe, open this link in a web browser:
https://gcn.nasa.gov/unsubscribe/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJlbWFpbCI6InZzbmV0L…
TITLE: GCN CIRCULAR
NUMBER: 36282
SUBJECT: LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA S240422ed: X-ray Upper Limits from EP-WXT for the Potential Electromagnetic Counterparts Reported by Swift and DECam
DATE: 24/04/24 13:14:11 GMT
FROM: EP Team at NAOC/CAS <ep_ta(a)bao.ac.cn>
H. N. Yang, Y. L. Wang, W. J. Zhang, X. Pan, X. P. Xu, C. C. Jin, D. Y. Li, H. Sun, Y. Liu, Z. X. Ling, C. Zhang, W. Chen, H. Q. Cheng, C. Z. Cui, D. W. Fan, H. B. Hu, J. W. Hu, M. H. Huang, J. J. Jin, T. Y. Lian, H. Y. Liu, M. J. Liu, Z. Z. Lv, X. Mao, H. W. Pan, W. X. Wang, Q. Y. Wu, Y. F. Xu, W. Yuan, M. Zhang, W. D. Zhang, Z. Zhang, D. H. Zhao (NAOC, CAS), Q. C. Shui (IHEP, CAS), E. Kuulkers, A. Santovincenzo (ESA), P. O'Brien (Univ. of Leicester), K. Nandra, A. Rau (MPE), B. Cordier (CEA), on behalf of the Einstein Probe team
We report on the X-ray upper limits from the ongoing observations of the Wide-field X-ray Telescope (WXT) on board the Einstein Probe (EP) mission, for the potential electromagnetic counterparts reported by Swift (Evans et al. GCN 36278) and DECam (Hu et al. GCN 36273).
Through our preliminary analysis of the WXT data, we found no significant X-ray counterparts at the positions of these sources, except for AT 2024hdq which is associated with a known Seyfert I galaxy LEDA 86073. The detected flux of this Seyfert by EP-WXT is around 2 x 10^-12 erg/s/cm2, consistent with the flux given in eRASS1. Upper limits for the other sources in 0.5-4 keV at the 90% confidence level are derived from the accumulated exposure from 2024-04-23 00:37:26 (UTC) to 2024-04-23 23:48:09 (UTC).
The flux upper limits at the 90% confidence level are detailed as follows.
Source | R.A | Dec. | Exposure (s) | Upper limit (erg/s/cm2)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AT 2024hdk | 130.625724 | -15.59953 | 20735 | 6.4 x 10^-12
AT 2024hdn | 127.302473 | -21.50639 | 27013 | 5.6 x 10^-12
AT 2024hdm | 126.65801 | -20.83375 | 26785 | 5.6 x 10^-12
AT 2024hdl | 125.472700 | -30.10220 | 39700 | 4.6 x 10^-12
AT 2024hdo | 120.866797 | -26.01212 | 50042 | 4.1 x 10^-12
AT 2024hdr | 120.804560 | -24.33268 | 39477 | 4.6 x 10^-12
AT 2024hdp | 120.543455 | -27.25787 | 42801 | 4.4 x 10^-12
S240422ed_X101 | 122.3954 | -24.3272 | 44192 | 4.4 x 10^-12
S240422ed_X190 | 121.2770 | -26.1203 | 48919 | 4.1 x 10^-12
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: the X-ray upper limit from EP-WXT for another potential electromagnetic counterpart of Swift, i.e. S240422ed_X61 has been given in our previous report (GCN 36270).
Follow-up observations with the Follow-up X-ray Telescope (FXT) of EP for the potential optical counterparts found by DECam have been carried out. For the two potential electromagnetic counterparts of Swift (S240422ed_X101, S240422ed_X190), we have also triggered quick follow-up observations with EP-FXT. Further results will be reported after the data analysis is completed.
The above observations were made with the WXT instrument during the commissioning phase of EP. Launched on January 9, 2024, EP is a space X-ray observatory to monitor the soft X-ray sky with X-ray follow-up capability (Yuan et al. 2022, Handbook of X-ray and Gamma-ray Astrophysics). EP is a mission of the Chinese Academy of Sciences in collaboration with ESA, MPE and CNES.
View this GCN Circular online at https://gcn.nasa.gov/circulars/36282.
---
To unsubscribe, open this link in a web browser:
https://gcn.nasa.gov/unsubscribe/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJlbWFpbCI6InZzbmV0L…
TITLE: GCN CIRCULAR
NUMBER: 36281
SUBJECT: LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA S240422ed: MOSFIRE spectroscopy of the DECam GW-MMADS candidate AT 2024hdn
DATE: 24/04/24 10:36:31 GMT
FROM: Mansi Kasliwal at Caltech <mansikasliwal(a)gmail.com>
Samaporn Tinyanont (NARIT), Jesper Sollerman (OKC), Jacob Jencson (IPAC), Viraj Karambelkar (Caltech), Michael Lundquist (WMKO) and Mansi Kasliwal (Caltech)
report on behalf of a larger collaboration
We obtained a near-infrared spectrum of the DECam GW-MMADS source AT2024hdn (GCN 36273), reported as a candidate optical counterpart to the LVK gravitational wave event S240422ed (GCN 36236) in the near-IR y-band with MOSFIRE on the Keck-I telescope on UTC 2024-04-24. The signal-to-noise on the transient is low and analysis is underway. In the reduced 2D spectrum, offset from the transient location, we note two prominent emisson lines at approx. 10161 Angstrom and 10679 Angstrom from the possible star formation knot / background galaxy north of the putative host. If these two lines are [SIII], this corresponds to a galaxy redshift of z=0.12 (significantly higher than the photometric redshift estimate of 0.079 from Bilicki et al. 2014). If this knot is at the same redshift as the transient, it would imply that AT 2024hdn has an absolute magnitude that is consistent with a supernova. We thank the WMKO staff and Keck I scheduled observers for their co-operation with these Target of Opportunity observations.
View this GCN Circular online at https://gcn.nasa.gov/circulars/36281.
---
To unsubscribe, open this link in a web browser:
https://gcn.nasa.gov/unsubscribe/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJlbWFpbCI6InZzbmV0L…
TITLE: GCN CIRCULAR
NUMBER: 36280
SUBJECT: LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA S240422ed: ATCA follow-up of candidate counterparts
DATE: 24/04/24 10:32:21 GMT
FROM: Dougal Dobie at University of Sydney <ddobie94(a)gmail.com>
D. Dobie, A. Gulati, T. Murphy (U. Sydney/OzGrav), J. Freeburn (Swinburne), A. Anumarlapudi, D.L. Kaplan (UWM) on behalf of a larger collaboration.
We report observations of Mag24a (GCN #36267) and the GW-MMADS source AT2024hdn (GCN #36273) with the Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA) on 2024-04-24 using 2x2048 MHz bands centered on 5.5 and 9 GHz.
We observed the position of Mag24a from 03:00-05:34 UTC. We chose to cease observations after independently discovering the red object at the position of the source in archival DECaPS2 data eventually reported in GCN #36274. We then observed the position of AT2024hdn from 05:35-07:40.
We do not find radio emission at the location of either optical source. After preliminary analysis of the data we report 3-sigma upper limits of
| Source | Frequency (GHz) | Flux density (uJy) |
| --------- | --------------- | ------------------ |
| Mag24a | 5.5 | < 55 |
| Mag24a | 9.0 | < 50 |
| AT2024hdn | 5.5 | < 240 |
| AT2024hdn | 9.0 | < 60 |
We thank CSIRO staff for rapidly scheduling these observations.
The Australia Telescope Compact Array is part of the Australia Telescope National Facility (https://ror.org/05qajvd42) which is funded by the Australian Government for operation as a National Facility managed by CSIRO. We acknowledge the Gomeroi people as the Traditional Owners of the Observatory site.
View this GCN Circular online at https://gcn.nasa.gov/circulars/36280.
---
To unsubscribe, open this link in a web browser:
https://gcn.nasa.gov/unsubscribe/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJlbWFpbCI6InZzbmV0L…
TITLE: GCN CIRCULAR
NUMBER: 36279
SUBJECT: LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA S240422ed: MOSFIRE imaging of the DECam GW-MMADS candidate AT 2024hdm
DATE: 24/04/24 09:01:56 GMT
FROM: Viraj Karambelkar at Indian Inst of Tech,Bombay <karambelkarvraj21197(a)gmail.com>
Viraj Karambelkar (Caltech), Jacob Jencson (IPAC), Samaporn Tinyanont
(NARIT), Mansi Kasliwal (Caltech) report on behalf of a larger
collaboration.
We imaged the DECam GW-MMADS source AT2024hdm (GCN 36273), reported as a
candidate optical counterpart to the LVK gravitational wave event S240422ed
(GCN 36236) in the near-IR J-band with MOSFIRE on the Keck-I telescope on
UTC 2024-04-24T07:48:25. This transient is close to a galaxy with photoz ~
0.048 (Bilicki et al. 2014), suggesting an absolute magnitude of M_r ~ -16
mag at discovery (GCN 36273, https://www.wis-tns.org/object/2024hdm).
We detect AT2024hdm in the J-band with m_J ~ 20.4 +/- 0.1 mag (AB). Based
on the r-band discovery magnitude, the r - J color of this transient is ~
0.3 mag. Correcting for Galactic extinction of E(B-V) ~ 0.1 along this
direction gives a corrected (r-J)_corr ~ 0.15 +/- 0.1 mag, suggesting that
the intrinsic color is not particularly red at this phase.
This transient may be consistent with a supernova. We encourage
spectroscopic classification to determine the true nature of the source.
View this GCN Circular online at https://gcn.nasa.gov/circulars/36279.
---
To unsubscribe, open this link in a web browser:
https://gcn.nasa.gov/unsubscribe/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJlbWFpbCI6InZzbmV0L…
TITLE: GCN CIRCULAR
NUMBER: 36277
SUBJECT: LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA S240422ed: Early X-ray Upper Limits from EP-WXT for the LVK Sky Localization Region
DATE: 24/04/24 08:17:05 GMT
FROM: EP Team at NAOC/CAS <ep_ta(a)bao.ac.cn>
W. J. Zhang, Y. L. Wang, H. N. Yang, X. Pan, X. P. Xu, C. C. Jin, D. Y. Li, H. Sun, Y. Liu, Z. X. Ling, C. Zhang, W. Chen, H. Q. Cheng, C. Z. Cui, D. W. Fan, H. B. Hu, J. W. Hu, M. H. Huang, J. J. Jin, T. Y. Lian, H. Y. Liu, M. J. Liu, Z. Z. Lv, X. Mao, H. W. Pan, W. X. Wang, S. X. Wen, Q. Y. Wu, Y. F. Xu, W. Yuan, M. Zhang, W. D. Zhang, Z. Zhang, D. H. Zhao (NAOC, CAS), Q. C. Shui (IHEP, CAS), B. Zhang (UNLV), E. Kuulkers, A. Santovincenzo (ESA), P. O'Brien (Univ. of Leicester), K. Nandra, A. Rau (MPE), B. Cordier (CEA), on behalf of the Einstein Probe team
We report on the X-ray upper limits derived from early observations with the Wide-field X-ray Telescope (WXT) on board the Einstein Probe (EP) mission for the sky region of the LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA candidate NSBH event S240422ed (The LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Collaboration, GCN 36236).
A real-time EP-WXT observation serendipitously covered ~90 square degrees in the 90% credible region of the updated LVK sky localization (The LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Collaboration, GCN 36240) from 2024-04-22 21:21:23 UTC with an exposure time of 5900 seconds, 830 s before the trigger time of the gravitational wave (GW) event (T0). However, this observation was interrupted by the SAA passage from 2024-04-22 21:31:23 UTC to 2024-04-22 22:00:00 UTC, so only the data within [T0-830 s, T0-230 s] (Obs-1a) and [T0+1487 s, T0+36202 s] (Obs-1b) are useful. No significant X-ray counterpart was detected in these good time intervals. Flux upper limits in 0.5-4 keV at the 90% confidence level are derived from good exposure time before and after the interruption of the observation.
During the above observation, an EP Target-of-Opportunity observation (Obs-2) was triggered on the LVK sky localization region, with the WXT field-of-view covered almost all of the 90% credible region of GW localization. Through our sebsequent analysis of the WXT data, no significant X-ray counterparts were found. A flux upper limit in 0.5-4 keV at the 90% confidence level is derived from this observation.
The flux upper limits at the 90% confidence level are detailed as follows.
No. | Start time (UTC) | End time (UTC) | Effective Exposure (s) | Upper limit (erg/s/cm2)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Obs-1a | 2024-04-22 21:21:23 | 2024-04-22 21:31:23 | 600 | 4.1 x 10^-11
Obs-1b | 2024-04-22 22:00:00 | 2024-04-23 07:38:35 | 5300 | 1.3 x 10^-11
Obs-2 | 2024-04-23 00:37:26 | 2024-04-23 05:24:11 | 5100 | 1.3 x 10^-11
EP is currently observing a list of galaxies within the 90% GW region with its Follow-up X-ray Telescope (FXT). The WXT field-of-view is covering a large fraction of this GW region simultaneously. The monitoring campaign and subsequent data analysis are ongoing. Further results will be reported later.
The above observations were made with the WXT instrument during the commissioning phase of EP. Launched on January 9, 2024, EP is a space X-ray observatory to monitor the soft X-ray sky with X-ray follow-up capability (Yuan et al. 2022, Handbook of X-ray and Gamma-ray Astrophysics). EP is a mission of the Chinese Academy of Sciences in collaboration with ESA, MPE and CNES.
View this GCN Circular online at https://gcn.nasa.gov/circulars/36277.
---
To unsubscribe, open this link in a web browser:
https://gcn.nasa.gov/unsubscribe/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJlbWFpbCI6InZzbmV0L…